Transmission overkill

merc-9spThe 2012 Mer­cedes S-Class sedans will have 9-speed trans­mis­sions. The idea is for them to have the smoothest and qui­etest shifts you can get.

To me, it’s overkill. Yes, refine­ment is great, but it is worth the extra expense? Our Honda mini­van has a 5-speed trans­mis­sion, which is won­der­ful. At high­way speeds, it’s purring along at a very low rate of rpm’s. Our Toy­ota sedan makes do with just a 3-speed. That both­ers me a bit, know­ing that it would save some fuel if the engine spun at lower rpm’s in top gear.

I remem­ber 10-speed bicy­cles being an inno­va­tion in the USA. My 1972 Gitane road bike came with a 10-speed. I upgraded it to a 12. Today most road bikes have 27 speeds. I’d be happy with 18. (Actu­ally, I am happy with 12 — but I’d appre­ci­ate the dif­fer­ence 18 would add to my cycling experience.)

Did you like this? Share it:

Comments

  1. Tim says:

    My dad’s bike seems to be a 21-speed. I took it out for a spin last night. Even with a split seat, it’s still a lot of pres­sure on the prostate... maybe I need to lower it a hair. But I did my neigh­bor­hood cir­cuit all in high-gear 6. Not likely to need the small­est front sprocket in TX. Ten was enough gears even in Aspen. (I took my bike in 1982.)

    The Murano Dad and Jan bought has some kind of trans­mis­sion (CVT) that sup­pos­edly does no shift­ing. I don’t know how it works exactly, but accord­ing to Wikipedia it’s a chain between two pul­leys that widen or nar­row accord­ing to speed/load.

Speak Your Mind

*