Governmental regulation can be good

Dodge Dart Grille, courtesy of Autoweek MagazineBack in the 1970s, air pol­lu­tion was really bad. The aver­age car back then put out lit­er­ally 20 times the amount of harm­ful emis­sions than today’s aver­age car. If the gov­ern­ment had not stepped in and made laws that forced car man­u­fac­tur­ers to clean up what was com­ing out of tailpipes, I am sure we’d have dirt­ier air today.

I haven’t been to China, but I under­stand the air in Bei­jing is a lot worse than the air in any Amer­i­can city. Why? A lack of gov­ern­men­tal regulation.

I fully under­stand that not all gov­ern­men­tal inter­ven­tions in life and pub­lic pol­icy are ben­e­fi­cial. But some are.

I chal­lenge you to argue with me on this one.

The photo is an enlarge­ment of a shot from Autoweek Mag­a­zine. Their May 14, 2012 issue has an arti­cle about the new Dodge Dart. Its front grille shuts at cer­tain speeds to improve fuel econ­omy — because of gov­ern­men­tal reg­u­la­tions for car man­u­fac­tur­ers to increase fuel econ­omy. I think that’s awesome.

Duplicate sets of cars

Floyd Mayweather, Jr's carsSo there’s a boxer. His name is Floyd May­weather, Jr. He has two iden­ti­cal sets of cars — a white set in Las Vegas and a black set in Miami. Each set includes a Bent­ley, a Mer­cedes Benz SLS AMG, a Fer­rari and an unknown fourth car. My guess on the total value (and there may be more than four cars) is about $2 mil­lion. Some­how it’s not the money spent that both­ers me. It’s the identical-but-different-color aspect.

Of course I’m think­ing of how one man has all those opu­lent and amaz­ing cars, and how the money could have been spent on a slightly bet­ter edu­ca­tion for kids in either city. Or how some kids in Africa might not die because they have clean water.

But some­how I mostly think of what a strange thing is is to have two identical-but-different-color sets of cars.

(Thanks to the May 10, 2012 Rolling Stone Mag­a­zine for the arti­cle fea­tur­ing this photo.)

Badge inflation

Mercedes Benz SLMer­cedes and BMW are both guilty of padding their num­bers. Not in a finan­cial sense but rather in mak­ing their prod­ucts appear larger than what they really are. This reflects an accu­rate under­stand­ing of how Amer­i­cans value big­ger things.

The forth-coming Mer­cedes SL550 has a 4.7 liter engine. It used to be that Mer­cedes would badge such a model as the SL470. No longer. BMW does the same thing with their 328i ... the lat­est model has a 2.0 liter engine.

In Europe, this infla­tion is slightly less. The SL550 is badged as the SL500.

Engine sizes are going down, as vehi­cle man­u­fac­tur­ers are fig­ur­ing out how to get more power out of less engine. That’s a good thing. Fuel econ­omy usu­ally goes up when these changes hap­pen. And then you save when you fill up at the gas station.

I long for the day when real num­bers will be given for things.

Photo cour­tesy of Desertspot­ter.

More about cars

Just a lit­tle reminder that I write over at Tum­blr too. And not exclu­sively about cars.

The teaser at left is part of a post that I recently did about the new Toy­ota Prius c.

Excess vs. Reality

Aston Martin DBS Volante Carbon Edition interior, courtesy of Elite ChoiceAston Mar­tin spends 25 hours pol­ish­ing the paint of their new DBS Volante Car­bon Edi­tion. And more than 70 hours of stitch­ing the leather inte­rior. That’s part of why the car costs $302,000.

I would never be able to own such a car. Even if I could afford it, my con­science would pre­vent me from sink­ing that much money into a car that gets me to the gro­cery store as well as our Toy­ota Corolla. Or maybe the Corolla would do it bet­ter, since it will hold more bags of gro­ceries. (My guess is that most Volante own­ers have some­one else do their gro­cery shop­ping, so that’s prob­a­bly not an issue.)

But some­how it com­forts me to know that this car exists. It’s not superla­tive in any cat­e­gory, but it is a work of art. An arti­cle in Autoweek mag­a­zine told the story of some kids in a mini­van see­ing the car across two lanes of traf­fic. They were so wowed by the car that they shouted out to the dri­ver, “Rev the engine! Rev the engine!” This car def­i­nitely has a pow­er­ful presence.

I’m torn. I know that any­one who spends $302,000 on a car could spend that money feed­ing starv­ing peo­ple. Maybe they haven’t ever lived in Africa, like I have. While we were there, we had friends who didn’t know where their next meal was com­ing from. And just $10 might feed their fam­ily for sev­eral days. That real­ity that makes me pause before I make any extrav­a­gant pur­chase. Can I really jus­tify it?

Photo cour­tesy of Elite Choice.

Review: Fisker Karma vs BMW 335d

Fisker Karma carSuper high-performance and green? As you think about your next lux­ury sedan, you may be think­ing about buy­ing a Fisker Karma.

I say that fully kid­ding — I know that none of my read­ers are think­ing about buy­ing a Fisker Karma.

Any­how, I read with inter­est a Car & Dri­ver mag­a­zine review of the new Fisker Karma. Think of it as a much faster Chevro­let Volt with a super beau­ti­ful body.

The gas engine pow­ers a gen­er­a­tor that charges an elec­tric motor that moves the wheels. So it can run only on elec­tric power for about 25 miles.

Why am I com­par­ing the $116,000 Karma to a $44,000 BMW 335d? Here are sev­eral reasons:

1. Per­for­mance? The BMW is faster than the Karma... BMW = 0–60 miles per hour in 5.3 sec­onds. The Fisker does 6.1 seconds.

2. Inte­rior room? Similar.

3. Qual­ity of mate­ri­als, fit and fin­ish? Similar.

4. Fuel econ­omy? BMW wins... 27 miles per gal­lon vs. the Fisker’s 24.

5. Green? Dis­pos­ing of all those lithium-ion bat­ter­ies when they fail to hold a charge any­more will be a night­mare. And diesel is more dirty than gas in some mea­sures but cleaner in others.

BMW 335dThe Fisker is a clear win­ner in the dis­tinc­tive­ness realm. You won’t see another on your block, guar­an­teed — no mat­ter where you live. But for every­thing else, the BMW wins.

A final note: the Porsche Panam­era S Hybrid is def­i­nitely a closer vehi­cle to com­pare. It costs a closer $95,000, does 0–60 in 5.7 sec­onds and gets 25 mpg.

Pho­tos are cour­tesy of the Fisker and BMW websites.

Cars: Choose Your Loss

2 station wagonsWhen you buy a car, you have a choice to make: fun or prac­ti­cal. Fun = expen­sive. Prac­ti­cal = sav­ing money in the long or short run.

Case in point: these two wag­ons were for sale locally, for rel­a­tively low prices. When com­pared to the orig­i­nal prices, the BMW was an incred­i­ble steal. How­ever, the BMW will end up cost­ing way more than the Ford, in prac­ti­cally every way you can imag­ine. (Trust me on this; I had an old BMW for a few years.)

But every sin­gle minute behind the wheel of the 528 (when it is run­ning OK, that is) will be way more enjoy­able than every minute behind the wheel of the Escort.

You must pick your poison.

(And I dream of poi­son. When I saw that BMW, I thought a lit­tle too long on how fun it would be to have it. Alas, we will con­tinue to drive one of the most bor­ing — and prac­ti­cal — cars on the planet, the Toy­ota Corolla.)

The rental car experience

Rental car gaugesOur mini­van was in the shop for a few weeks. Some­one (ahem, not me) did some dam­age to the body that took a while to repair. We have fan­tas­tic car insur­ance, so our insur­ance com­pany paid for a rental car for the whole time.

The rental car was a Dodge Avenger — a “mid-sized” Amer­i­can sedan — pretty generic. The qual­ity was not bad. There were a few details that didn’t quite mea­sure up. One was the ensem­ble of gauges. (If you click on the image, you can see more detail.) Sit­ting straight-ahead, the left edge of the tachome­ter was not vis­i­ble. And the type­face for the speedome­ter was a really poor choice.

A very fun aspect to the rental car expe­ri­ence was the sur­prise that awaited me when I loaded up a CD... there was already a CD in the player. So I pushed it back in. Cheezy, syrupy Chi­nese pop music filled the car.

Chinese music CDJust before return­ing the car, I faced a dilemma. I had for­got­ten to take a photo of the CD to share with you. So would I leave the CD in there as a sur­prise for the next renter who would try to lis­ten to a CD? Or should I bring it home so I could take a photo? Alas, pass­ing on the bless­ing to the next renter went by the way­side. So I’m pass­ing on the bless­ing to you (minus the audio portion).

Fun vs. Practical

Letter to Automobile magazineThis let­ter appears in the Decem­ber 2011 issue of Auto­mo­bile Magazine.

I love writ­ing let­ters to the edi­tor. This is my 15th or 16th let­ter to get pub­lished in a national or inter­na­tional mag­a­zine. I get a buzz out of see­ing my name in print. Ego­tis­ti­cal? Maybe. (For­give me for that, if it’s true.)

Roughly the same amount of time it would take for you to com­ment on a blog post — and have 21 peo­ple see it — can yield a few more views, if your thoughts are pub­lished in a mag­a­zine. Print may be dying, but there is still a good num­ber of peo­ple who read printed mag­a­zines. Obvi­ously, I’m one.

If you’d like to read more of the dead Volvo story, it’s in my pre­vi­ous blog.

And here’s Ezra’s col­umn. The Decem­ber Auto­mo­bile Let­ters to the Edi­tor sec­tion had more let­ters about that col­umn than I’ve ever seen focus­ing on any arti­cle or col­umn before.

One step forward, two back

Mobile charging stationI doubt if you read Autoweek mag­a­zine. That’s why I’m shar­ing this story from the Octo­ber 31, 2011 issue.

AAA now has trucks devoted to charg­ing stranded elec­tric cars in six dif­fer­ent US cities. At the moment, that would only be two vehi­cles — the Nis­san Leaf and the Mis­tubishi i. And there are maybe 25 actual cars float­ing around the US. So it’s a near-future-oriented program.

Any­how, I was amused at the thought of a rel­a­tively low fuel econ­omy truck being dri­ven across town to charge up an “ultra-green” car. It kind of defeats the purpose.

Another strange thing is that the trucks charge up the cars to travel another 3–15 miles ... to “reach a charg­ing sta­tion.” Good luck find­ing a charg­ing sta­tion. You might know that most fully-electric cars take about 24 hours to charge from a reg­u­lar house­hold cir­cuit. (A devoted 240– or 480-volt out­let drops the full charge time down to 3–6 hours.)

My con­struc­tive sug­ges­tion? Use a much cheaper tow truck and tow the car to the owner’s home. Or an office or store that has an elec­tric exten­sion cord.

Elec­tric cars aren’t ready for prime time. Yet.